WARNING: This posting discusses the Arab-Israeli conflict. If you have a strong (or

biased) opinion on this issue, you may not want to read ahead. Continue at your own risk.
(Right - Here is the area where we met with the Palestinians to hear about their village, Silwan, and what it is like for them with the archeology going on right in the middle of it. This sign mentions the digging that is going on under the village, damaging homes and streets).Today as an interesting day. I studied a little this morning since our last final is coming up. Then this afternoon I went with a group going on a tour called Alternative Archeology. We went to the City of David (where we'd already been) but got a different perspective on things.
The point of this group is to keep archeology neutral, rather than have it be used only to benefit a certain group of people. For example, the work being done at the City of David is all Israel

i-oriented, forgetting about the numerous other cultures who have resided there. The history of that area, as far as we know, begins about 2000 BC.
(Left - the damaged street after being fixed. Even after fixing it, the street is still sunken in).The Israelites did not live there until David's time, about 1000 BC. That is a thousand years of history that is ignored! After that, the Israelites lived there (as Jews) until 70 AD when Jews were no longer allowed in the city. The dominant culture was Greco-Roman until 638 years when the dominant culture became the Arab Muslims which became Crusader for a few in 1099. All of that is ignored in the search for Israeli artifacts. Honestly, that doesn't bug me as much as the fact that their archeology is done with no concern for the residents. Homes are taken without compensation, people are not allowed to build on land they own, and sometimes that land is taken for public use, such as parking lots. The other major problem is that archaeologists are digging under the surround area, destabilizing the homes and streets. Here is an interesting, but true story. The street was damaged, it sunk in in parts. The Palestinian residents called to get it fixed. They were told that they would have to wait and call back later. One of the Palestinians had an Israeli friend call and say she was a settler in that area. With a half an hour, the government sent people to fix the street.
Here is another interesting, but true story. I've talked about settlers before. Settlers would not be a problem if their intentions were different. Now, I'm usually very careful about ascribing intentions to other people because we can't really know their motives. However, in this case, it seems obvious. The settlers specifically move into Palestinian areas in attempt to take over those areas for Israelis. I say this because if they wanted to live peaceful in

those areas, they would not come in with the level of security that they do (tons of expensive cameras, arms, security guards, fences, etc).
(Right - here you can see three security cameras in a tiny area. The Palestinians say that they feel watched. Can you blame them?) Now, you might say, but they feel unsafe! Then ask yourselves, why would you DELIBERATELY move into a place where you feel unsafe? One of the Palestinians with whom we talked told us about his grandmother. When she died, the settlers stole her thumb print and forged papers saying that she had sold them her house before she died. They moved in. The family of the deceased went to court and the court ruled in their favor, having discovered the forgery. So, do you think those settlers moved out? No, they are still there. They appeal and re-appeal, knowing that the Palestinians do not have the money to continue to battle in court. Once settlers move in, they never move out. Many of the houses they acquire, they acquire illegally. Others, they acquire legally, though maybe not fairly.
Anyway, it was interesting to see a different side to archeology. The City of David used to be called something else, but the Israelis changed the name and the names of streets to, as they say it, Judaize the area.
No comments:
Post a Comment